Club supports CLEAN MONEY in politics
Click here for information


V, V for VICTORY!  by Marcy Winograd

Let us thank Lt. Governor John Garamendi and State Controller John Chiang for voting down the proposed 14-story-high LNG terminal Australia's BHP Billiton wanted to build off the Malibu and Oxnard coast.  Our Palisades Democratic Club Executive Board voted overwhelmingly to oppose the project, writing letters and calling commissioners to urge them to reject it.

After a long day of testimony on April 9th, the State Lands Commission voted against the project 2-1, with only Schwarznegger's appointee voting for the terminal.

This means the Malibu/Oxnard project is, in all probability, dead.  (More LNG proposals are on the docket for Los Angeles County though, so stay tuned ...)

Though newspaper accounts mentioned a crowd of 500, the head count was more like 2,000 at the Oxnard Performing Arts Center, where Maureen Cruise and I planned to testify on behalf of the Palisades Democratic Club.  Amidst a sea of blue Sierra Club "Terminate the Terminal" t-shirts, our Assemblywoman Julia Brownley, our former Assemblywoman Fran Pavley, Chumash healers, Malibu's Pierce & Keeley Brosnan, the incredible former PUC commissioner Loretta Lynch, Mayor Maricela Morales of Pt. Hueneme, Santa Barbara Democratic activist Bob Handy, a rabbi, scientists, actors and activists spoke of asthma, smog, greenhouse gasses, and environmental racism (the pipes would run through Oxnard, a city over 70% Latino).

Days before the California Coastal Commission had released an environmental impact report noting the LNG terminal would create unacceptable levels of air pollution and worsen greenhouse gases.

With the doors shut, the room so crowded the fire marshal was sending warning notes to commissioners conducting the hearing, school children stood outside, their faces pushed up against the glass to get a peek at the action.  In the end, we never testified, ceding our time out of respect to a Sierra Club organizer who asked the crowd to forgo further testimony so the official deciders could vote on the issue before everyone had to go home.
 
"All those opposed to the project please stand up," said the Sierra Club organizer.  Hundreds shot to their feet.  Before the next name was called, Lt. Gov. John Garamendi, who chaired the hearings, added, "Wait a minute.  All those in favor of the project please stand."  

Only five suits slowly rose from their chairs. Were they Billiton reps or Oxnard Chamber of Commerce men?
 
Yes, it's lonely at the top of an LNG terminal.  
 
The vote to nix the project was a great victory for our children and our children’s children and for all of us who grew up body surfing off the coast off Malibu.  I remember the waves, sometimes gentle, other times furious, crashing over and under me as I rode to shore on the best amusement ride in the world.  When we looked back, we saw, smelled, inhaled only the mysteries of the sea, never an LNG terminal towering over the waves, spewing noxious particles.  
 
Iraq.  Darfur. Katrina.  Horror and heartache are everywhere, but beauty is what binds us to this glorious earth.  Our California coast is a gem, so let’s keep up the good fight to protect it.